
Secretary Clinton and President Obama in Lisbon, November 19, 2010
Good morning, sleepyheads. Wonk the Vote here with my two for this Saturday, November 20th, 2010. Eighty five years ago today, Bobby Kennedy was born. On November 3rd, 1964, the voters of New York elected Bobby Kennedy to the US Senate. Thirty six years later, on November 7th, 2000, the voters of New York elected Hillary Rodham Clinton to the seat that had once belonged to Bobby. Hillary earned 55 percent of the vote, nearly the same as Bobby Kennedy’s 54 percent in 1964. Over eight years later, toward the end of the 2008 race between Clinton and Obama, much was made of Hillary’s RFK remarks — much ado about absolutely nothing. The photo to the left, from yesterday in Lisbon, is testament to just how baseless and phony the outrage over Hillary’s comments had been from the start.
Months before, back in January 2008, when the banshee choir’s chant of “Why Won’t That Stupid Bitch Quit” was still in its infancy, RFK’s children had endorsed Hillary Clinton for president. Their endorsement prompted Stephen Schlesinger to pen an op-ed for the Huffington Post called “Hillary and RFK” underscoring the thread between Bobby’s career and Hillary’s:
It is interesting to read the op-ed piece in Tuesday’s Los Angeles Times (Jan 29, 2008) written by three of Robert Kennedy’s children — Kathleen Kennedy Townsend, Robert F. Kennedy, Jr., and Kerry Kennedy, endorsing the candidacy of Hillary Clinton. The match-up of RFK’s offspring with Hillary Clinton is, on one level, a personal and passionate embrace of a woman whom all of them greatly admire for her political prowess and broad vision. But, on another level, it is a symbolic reminder to America of how similar Hillary’s and RFK’s political experiences have been — and what lessons we can draw from them.
First, all political analogies are imperfect. Still the similarities are quite atonishing. Both individuals, we should remember, started their political careers with famous last names. Like RFK, Hillary ran for the U.S. Senate in NY State as an outsider and won. Like him, she won the adoring support of New Yorkers. But, like him, the moment she jumped into the presidential race, she was labeled ruthless and unprincipled. And like him she has faced an opponent who is considered a “breakthrough” candidate, a man of change. In the case of RFK, voters were eventually able to see through the din and dust to his true progressive beliefs. In the case of Hillary Clinton, her triumphs in New Hampshire, Nevada and Michigan suggest that as more and more people listen to her, the more they are willing to embrace her as the most reliable liberal trailblazer in the contest.
It is Hillary whose life’s work echoes and embodies the spirit of Bobby Kennedy’s words in Cape Town, South Africa, June 1966:
“Each time a man stands up for an ideal, or acts to improve the lot of others, or strikes out against injustice, he sends forth a tiny ripple of hope, and crossing each other from a million different centers of energy and daring, those ripples build a current which can sweep down the mightiest walls of oppression and resistance.”
Interestingly enough, this week ended with another faux-controversy ala Hillary’s RFK remarks, this time with the White House getting its panties in a bunch over James Carville reiterating his joke from 2008:
“If Hillary gave up one of her balls and gave it to Obama, he’d have two.”
The truth is, Hillary has something that she cannot give to Obama no matter how hard she tries to help him. These are stripes earned. They cannot be transferred from her to him.
With her bid for the presidency, Hillary did exactly what Matt Taibbi doubted when he wrote the following in June of 2008:
So that was one problem with viewing Clinton’s campaign through that heroic prism, i.e., that of an inspirational female leader refusing to step aside when told by a male-dominated political hierarchy. The other was that I just don’t believe it.
Hillary Clinton, love her or hate her, is a fighter. You can disagree with her politics, indict her character, or tear down her womanhood all you want, but you will not be able to stop the fact that the world witnessed a woman who fought back and was resilient while the chattering classes declared open season on her and on her supporters, all while jumping the gun to write the political obituary of a woman who is still going strong today.
There was an actual assassination during the 2008 cycle—the one that took down Benazir Bhutto, which David Axelrod did not miss the chance to make about Hillary Clinton’s AUMF vote. That was the poor assassination comment during the 2008 primaries.
In stark contrast to Bhutto’s assassination was the imaginary assassination that the Clinton-deranged faction projected onto Hillary’s RFK remarks.
The thread between the Axlerod’s Bhutto remarks and the reaction to Hillary’s RFK remarks was the attempted character assassination against the Clintons—an attempt that failed.
This is obviously not a diary on RFK. Of the three Kennedy brothers, Bobby is the one I am drawn to, but I am sure someone who was actually alive when he was can write a much more fitting tribute of him on this November 20th, and I cannot wait to read it. I wrote this piece today because what is past is prologue and remembering Bobby on this day led me straight to Hillary and the line between their careers. Reminiscent of Bobby and the Kennedy legacy, Hillary is the Clinton who we came so close to having as our president but fell short. Unlike with Bobby, there is still a chance Hillary could run again. But, if she does not, that is our loss. Not Hillary’s.
If you see Hillary now, she is happier than ever and is living out history, doing the work she was born for, fighting not just for women and girls but for the progress of us all, which cannot happen without the rights and roles and voices of women.
And, on that note, I would like turn you to three different profiles on three very different women.
The first woman is Ela Bhatt, who Hillary presented the first ever Global Fairness Initiative award to this week at the Kennedy Center. A few excerpts of Hillary’s comments in honor of Ela:
And tonight, we are honoring a woman whose work has been at the leading edge of the fight against poverty.
A great deal has already been said and written over the years about Ela’s impact on India and the world. About the innovative programs she pioneered, making it possible for the very poor to gain access to services that were once the sole purview of the well-off—like credit, like banking, sick leave, and child care. Or about her conviction that women are the key to progress—that investing in women is one of the most powerful ways to fight poverty.
But tonight, I’d like to consider Ela’s impact from another angle. The work that she has done through the Self-Employed Women’s Association is not only about finding solutions to the problems of poverty. At its most basic level, Ela’s work is about fairness, about giving every person the chance to achieve his or her dreams, to make the most of his or her God-given potential—no matter how rich or poor, no matter whether they work in a factory or a home or on the side of a road.
Next up is Cathleen Black, who is Bloomberg’s pick to lead New York’s schools – the NY Times ran this piece called, “A Trailblazer With Her Eye on the Bottom Line”:
“She’s the closest thing to Superman that exists,” said Atoosa Rubenstein, on whom Ms. Black placed an audacious bet, letting her start a new magazine, CosmoGirl, at age 26.
Hmm, the closest thing to Superman? That’s not exactly inspiring. NY Mag has this breakdown of NYT’s profile on Black:
The Times dispatched a journalistic SWAT team of fourteen reporters to uncover information about her, and they basically discovered she’s a powerful woman in a stylish gray flannel power suit.
I’m running out of time, so click on the NYT and NY Mag links to get the dish on Cathie Black and judge for yourself. (There’s also this bit from the NYT City Room blog about Black’s appearance on The Apprentice.)
Last but not least, Melanne Verveer, in the words of Hillary who introduced Melanne this Wednesday at the National Women’s Law Center Award dinner (state.gov video and transcript at the link; Hillary also gives shout outs to Brooksley Born and Geena Davis):
Melanne has been a dear friend as well as a colleague. And she actually, along with her wonderful husband Phil, went to college with Bill. So we have had a very close, personal relationship. And then 18 years ago we started working together and it was the beginning of an epic journey that has taken us together and separately on behalf of the work we love to every corner of the world. We’ve been sitting together under sweltering tents in a village in India or at a meeting with thousands of civil society activists packed in that room in Huairou, China in 1995 or going to a housing development, literally, built from the ground up by formerly homeless women squatters in South Africa, and so many other places that flash through my mind like the movie that reminds me of everything that we have done on behalf of women and girls.
Before I end this morass of a post, a few words on another birthday boy…
With all due respect and birthday wishes to Vice President Joe Biden , why on earth does he have to keep going around even dignifying the rumor mill that Hillary Clinton will replace him on the ticket in 2012? Why will he not just laugh it off with some good humor? I cannot understand Biden’s public reactions at all.
Until Obama and Hillary ever prove otherwise, I for one do not buy the chatter of an Obama/Clinton do-over as anything other than the internet chain letter it started out as within days after Obama announced Biden as his VP pick. And, yet it strikes me as telling that Biden is not only asked about being replaced by Hillary but has yet to shrug off the talk effortlessly without getting into how wanted a Vice President he was and how his parents have reassured him he was not any kind of a mistake. Gah.
It is yet more evidence that Hillary earned something in 2008 that all the male suits running against her did not.
Well that’s it for me, this is Wonk signing off… hoping against Hope, pour la liberté, égalité et sororité… and since this is a birthday boy post on a Shero Saturday–all the way from Bobby to Hillary–I’ll go the extra mile to add back the fraternité mention for our like-minded brotherhood out there. I hope you have a great weekend, and as always, I welcome you to use the comments to share your two cents and Saturday reads:
[youtube=http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=baiOAROK_xQ&w=300&showinfo=0]
Bernice Johnson Reagon,
“Come and Go with Me to that Land”
Come and go with me to that land
Where I’m bound
I got a brother in that land
Where I’m bound
I got a sister in that land
Where I’m bound
We’ll all be together in that land
Where I’m bound
Come and go with me to that land
Where I’m bound